Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Culture

Meat Versus “Meat”: The Battle Between Farmers and Scientists

The search for a guilt-free hamburger is on, and cell-based meat looks to be a solution, but is is?

scribbled up burger

This debate is gonna get a lil’ messy. Via

I grew up in a meat-loving family, but loved to rebel. When I told my parents I wanted to go vegan, the general consensus was, “We’ll see how long that lasts.” To be honest, they were right to be skeptical. It’s hard to go completely cold turkey when you’ve been raised on a fully omnivorous diet, as Jessica Glenza attests to in their article for The Gaurdian, “Inside the impossible burger: is the eat-free mega trend as good as we think?” I am here to say, as a former vegan, no. It is not even close to as good as we think.

I won’t lie to the public. I am well aware of how unethical eating chow is for so many reasons. Agriculture and farming heavily contribute to greenhouse gases and ocean dead zones caused by industrial farming waste, reports Glenza. However, when I went vegan, I watched a documentary called Cowspiracy (2014) co-directed by Kip Andersen and Keegan Kuhn, which also questions and criticizes the sustainability of industrial farming. You can find the documentary here.

Nelore cow grazing in a field during sunset.

Despite many of their similarities, the two sides of the meat industry have been at war. Many farmers claim cell-based meat shouldn’t be labeled as meat, insisting that true meat is “harvested in the traditional manner.” Thus, the debate began. Cell-based supporters offer up “clean meat,” and country boys argue that implies their meat is “dirty.”

The Debate Between Regulated Cell-Cultured And Traditional Meat

The debate continues over whether the FDA should regulate cell-cultured aliment as unique products or the USDA as traditional meat. Here is how I side in this heated debate. If cell-based meats become more eco-friendly and ethical, I’ll support them. Until then, I’ll feel guilty eating a Big Mac. Despite many of their similarities, the two sides of the meat industry have been at war. Many farmers have argued that cell-based meat should not even be able to call itself chow, defining fare as something “harvested in the traditional manner.” Thus, the debate began. Cell-based supporters offer up “clean meat,” and country boys argue that that implies their meat is “dirty.” The debate continues: should cell-cultured meat be regulated by the FDA for unique products or the USDA for traditional meat? Here is how I side in this heated debate.

Its all pretty damn bad.

We don’t have enough statistics to prove that cell-based farming is going to make enough of a difference environmentally. I don’t think we should discredit the research, but if you’re looking to feel a little less guilty when you eat a hamburger, this isn’t the solution. Cell-based meat is taking a hands-clean approach to slaughter, allowing someone else to do the dirty work, and have them reap the benefits. Whether its from the guilt or the cholesterol, we’ll never know (I know) ((it’s the cholesterol)).

Here are some tips for those who are looking to switch to a vegan diet and lifestyle.

Written By

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Support Real Ones. Fund the Future.

If you read this far, you get it: young voices matter. At TRILL, every story is written by emerging writers telling the truth in a media landscape that too often silences them.

We run ads, yeah. But they don’t run us. We’re independent, mission-driven, and powered by people who believe young storytellers deserve more than just “exposure.”

Your donation goes straight to mentorship, editorial support, and launching the next wave of Gen Z writers into media careers that matter.

If that matters to you, chip in. Even $5 helps keep TRILL free, fearless, and independent.

Donate Now →

You May Also Like

Books

Celebrate Pride Month with these moving literary depictions of the queer experience.

Opinion

I believe in science. But what does that actually mean? What does having faith in science mean?

Opinion

A cultural deep-dive into Diet Coke’s symbolic role in diet culture. From 1980s marketing to TikTok aesthetics and influencer-fueled wellness trends.

Opinion

Why is Gen-Z in the center of the generation wars? What it looks like to playfully banter between age gaps and why we do...